About this Entry
Posted by: MyxlDove

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site

Original: 9/20/2012 2:16 PM
Views: 738
Comments: 40
eProps: 48

Read Comments
Post a Comment
Back to Your Xanga Site

Thursday, September 20, 2012

PSA: The Truth About Comments

 

Have you ever tried to figure out one surefire way to drive traffic to your blog? NEWSFLASH: There isn't one. Have you ever wondered what makes someone leave a comment on one of your posts, but then fail to leave a comment on another? (This can be particularly frustrating if a subsequent post you feel was even better goes ignored. ) Has it ever crossed your mind that there may be something external to all that you do that affects the flow of traffic to your blog? I know I've asked these questions before. Maybe you have too.

I got a lot of wonderful comments one of my posts a couple years ago about a favorite blogger of mine "Leaving". One of my favorite comments was left by BohemianLotus who plainly stated, "you can't hold it against someone else if they don't comment on your blog. No one should judge the quality of their own blogs in terms of being worthy of feedback. It either is, or isn't, and it's up to the people giving the feedback to decide on that." I've found that to be true 100% of the time. We don't know what goes through the minds of those who read our posts. There could be a thousand different reasons why they do or don't decide to leave a comment. Here are some of mine:

  • WORK: 90% of the time I'm blogging while at work. During that time, I visit a lot of blogs on which I plan to leave substantial comments. I'm not in the habit of leaving comments that consist of one or two words like "I agree" or "Well said". I try to offer people a little more than textual evidence of my visit. But, my workload fluctuates (meetings, deadlines, etc.) and that affects my ability to get back to those posts. Sometimes I'll have a post open for hours before actually finding the time to read it and then leave a comment.
  • READING: Before I leave a comment, I read the entire post. This should be a given. But people usually comment for three different reasons. And I know of more than a few people who never read an entire post. Some posts are painfully tl;dr. But if it's by one of my favorite bloggers, I'll push through it anyway. This takes time and may affect whether or not I get a chance to comment.
  • CONTEXT: Some posts just don't lend themselves to comments. I mean, if you're pouring out your heart in a way that is just meant to allow you to vent, it may not be necessary (or appropriate) to say anything. In some of these cases, I might follow up with a message if the blogger needs someone to talk to.
  • FAVORITES: If you're one of my favorite bloggers, I will most likely check out your blog first before going through my subs to see if you've posted something new. I will actually do this before writing my own posts, since I don't usually check out my subs until I've posted for the day. This doesn't necessarily mean I'll leave a comment, but it certainly increases the chances.
  • TITLES: I will check out your post if the title is interesting. This is especially important if you're a new blogger, or at least someone I'm not subbed to who has been REC'd by people whose opinions I respect.
  • CONTENT: This should go without saying, but what you write is probably themost important factor. If it's controversial purely to stir up drama, I'll avoid it. If it's incoherent and seems like you were asleep when you wrote it, I'll avoid it. If it's antagonistic to another blogger, I'll avoid it. But if it's witty, provides insight into your character, discusses things that are passionate to you, or asks for feedback, I'm all over that.

This is by no means an exhaustive list of reasons, but these are definitely some of the more important factors that affect my ability/willingness to comment on your posts. You shouldn't take a lack of commenting as a reflection on the quality of your blog. A lot of times I'm far more aware of people who happen to be active on any given day. So if you don't post one day, I may not get back to comment your post that I missed the day before.



Can you relate to these factors?
Does anyone feel the same way?

 Posted 9/20/2012 2:16 PM - 738 Views - 48 eProps - 40 comments

Give eProps or Post a Comment

40 Comments

browse comments: next › | last »


Visit grizzlybearr's Xanga Site!

i'm a horrible commenter. 9 times out of 10 i have NO IDEA what to say. lol. 

Posted 9/20/2012 8:59 AM by grizzlybearr Xanga True Member - recommend (1) - reply

Visit grizzlybearr's Xanga Site!

oh, but if you do have any tips on traffic, lend them my way. ;) i'm trying to get my blogger fitness-y blog out there and noticed

Posted 9/20/2012 9:00 AM by grizzlybearr Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit Thatslifekid's Xanga Site!

I enjoy leaving short comments. Maybe I'll just start leaving random combinations of words to confuse people now.


Future comment example:


hotdog, lamp.

Posted 9/20/2012 9:03 AM by Thatslifekid Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@grizzlybearr - I think the most sure fire way to generate traffic is to comment on other blogs. I guarantee that if you visit other people, a good percentage of them will visit you. They may just comment. But they might also subscribe. Do that enough times and you'll establish a pretty good audience. Just know that it takes work and it won't happen overnight. But I have definitely seen a return on spending the time on other blogs.

Posted 9/20/2012 9:03 AM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend (1) - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@Thatslifekid - Ha! We all know you can't cook a hotdog using a lamp! Oh wait, that was supposed to not make sense, right?

Posted 9/20/2012 9:04 AM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit Thatslifekid's Xanga Site!

@MyxlDove - perhaps I'll try again: pineapple, birdbath

Posted 9/20/2012 9:12 AM by Thatslifekid Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

Visit Tempguestbrief's Xanga Site!

my comments depend greatly on the content also... your reasons for avoiding some posts are very similar to mine.   I have no idea what quality my posts are, but I enjoy it when others find them interesting enough to comment on.  I also am grateful for comments that are there just because the commenter likes me and wants to say hi! 

Posted 9/20/2012 9:17 AM by Tempguestbrief Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit Megabyyte's Xanga Site!

sometimes I start to think, "how hard is it to think of something to say? Really!"

Ha, then I'll go to someone elses post and be like, "Uh,...."

So, sometimes I'll leave a short comment, because that's my way of basically saying, I read, I agree and that's about it! lol Or I'll leave just an "lol" or a smiley face for the same reason. I've had complaints about that, though.

Posted 9/20/2012 9:51 AM by Megabyyte Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit WaitingToShrug's Xanga Site!

@Thatslifekid - Bathapple, pinebird. 



Posted 9/20/2012 9:51 AM by WaitingToShrug - recommend - reply

Visit WaitingToShrug's Xanga Site!

YES, to the work thing. Almost all of my blogging/commenting takes place at work. I will open up tabs, and sometimes never get to them! Actually, yes to all the rest as well. You've got a good handle on xanga interactions. 

Posted 9/20/2012 9:52 AM by WaitingToShrug - recommend - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@Tempguestbrief - I understand. If I don't have anything to say, I'll sometimes just REC the post. I'm also the kind of person that will just say hi in a private message if we're friends.

@Megabyyte - Smiley faces are perfectly acceptable comments IMO.

@WaitingToShrug - Bathapple! I like that name!  If I could create something and call it that I'd be filthy rich! lol

Posted 9/20/2012 9:56 AM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit xdeelynnx's Xanga Site!

I have a list of "usuals" I always try to comment on as much as possible. With school, it's been a bit impossible lately.

Posted 9/20/2012 10:08 AM by xdeelynnx - recommend - reply

Visit randaness's Xanga Site!

When I go to read my subs, I open a bunch of tabs with everything I want to read. I usually read the shorter ones first, and ones that I think might need to be read (i.e., if the poster is going through a rough time or something). After that, the order tends to fluctuate. When I have a post open for a long time but still can't make it through the text or can't come up with anything to comment (or if the content was time-sensitive and they've since written a new post), I'll just close without doing anything. If I can't think of anything substantial to say in a comment, I won't leave one, unless I notice that I haven't left a comment in awhile (so it's not creepy that I always read a person's blog but don't comment).

Posted 9/20/2012 10:34 AM by online now randaness Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit heart_leigh's Xanga Site!

I must the only one who doesn't mind if someone drops by my blog and doesn't comment. If people do comment, that's great. And if they don't, no biggie.

Posted 9/20/2012 11:23 AM by heart_leigh - recommend - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@randaness - Yeah, you are totally creeping me out right now. But in a friendly "aww, we should talk more often" kind of way.

@heart_leigh - I don't mind if people don't comment either. I just wanted people to understand why I may not comment. Life can get in the way.

Posted 9/20/2012 11:27 AM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit randaness's Xanga Site!

@MyxlDove - Darn, I was going for chainsaw creepy. Guess I'll have to try again next post!

Posted 9/20/2012 11:33 AM by online now randaness Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@randaness - it's mostly the cat photo that makes me shudder.

Posted 9/20/2012 11:35 AM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit randaness's Xanga Site!

@MyxlDove - I have this one, too!

Posted 9/20/2012 11:35 AM by online now randaness Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit Randy7777's Xanga Site!

Commenting about commenting   ummmm        You must of run out of topics -lol 

Posted 9/20/2012 11:36 AM by Randy7777 Xanga True Member Xanga Premium Member - recommend - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@randaness - *sings* "I always feel like somebody's watchin' me!" lol

@Randy7777 - It's meta-blogging day... somewhere in the world. lol

Posted 9/20/2012 11:37 AM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit Crystalinne's Xanga Site!

I was here and I read it all the way through.

not sure what to say other than, sure we'd all love to see our works visited/commented upon, but as long as we are pleased with what we have put out there... yeah.

oh and I wonder if time of day influences people too. Do they just respond perhaps to top ones listed on their inbox when limited time and the others are forgotten so blogging when noone else is on might be a kiss of death for a post? IDK. What's your opinion on that?

Posted 9/20/2012 1:42 PM by Crystalinne - recommend - reply

Visit MyxlDove's Xanga Site!

@Crystalinne - Well, I know that some people despise time stamping. But I wrote a blog post about it nearly 4 years ago that went over the pros and cons. The truth is, people are not online at the same time throughout the day. And I would guess that MOST people rarely get past the first page of their inbox when deciding who to visit. So the best way to encourage interaction is to be in front of them. That could be writing several posts a day, which I did when I first joined more than 10 years ago. Or you can simply time stamp a post you've already written.

Posted 9/20/2012 2:47 PM by MyxlDove Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit BohemianLotus's Xanga Site!

One reason *I* might not comment on someone's blog is TINY ASS FONT makin' it hard to read. *ahem*  Even though I just did. 

Posted 9/20/2012 4:03 PM by BohemianLotus Xanga True Member Xanga Lifetime Member - recommend - reply

Visit viralblog's Xanga Site!

Hi,
I am new to this platform,I quite respect and agree with your views,your post is the and I believe the only post I will read today,and I passed may be three or four post before deciding to read yours,I don't know,should I say you never know what goes into bloggers head when they decide to read a post and leave anothe,and ake a comment on one without making on the other or should I say they never know where they are with themselves.I love your post keep it up!
Chukwuemeka Egwu

http://www.atoz-empowermenrnetwork.com

Posted 9/20/2012 4:16 PM by viralblog - recommend - reply

Visit galadrielspitcher's Xanga Site!

@grizzlybearr - lol...same for me.

Posted 9/20/2012 4:25 PM by galadrielspitcher Xanga True Member - recommend - reply

browse comments: next › | last »


Sign in to CommentChoose Identity
Give eProps (?)
Post a Comment
Add Link | Preview HTML comment help 
Profile Pic:
Default  |  Choose »  (?)

(?)

Back to MyxlDove's Xanga Site!
Note: your comment will appear in MyxlDove's local time zone:
GMT -08:00 (Pacific Standard - US, Canada)